Only a few hours from the season finale of Doctor Who. “The Wedding of River Song” is supposed to wrap up all the mysteries laid out in this confusing, but interesting season, and some that have been introduced in the 2008 season when the character of River Song was first introduced.
There are some who feel that the plot of the arc is too difficult to follow. I don’t think so. In fact, I prefer that the plot makes me think and try too figure it out, instead of letting my brain turn to mush while I watch it. However, if the seaon ends on some kind of deus ex machina, such as last years finale of the same show, I might not be to happy. Its easy to wrap up a story with “magic;” it is harder to do it without.
Doctor Who has been a kind of anthology show since its early days. With the TARDIS the Doctor can go anywhere and have any kind of adventure. Horror this week, comedy the next, sci-fi after that, and then the comedy-horror-sci-fi episode to knock your senses on their ass. Since the revival of the show (and the search for the Key to Time back in 1978 during Tom Baker’s reign as the TV Time Lord) each year has included an arc to the season. The Ninth Doctor dealt with the mystery of Bad Wolf, which became the template for the seasons to come after. With Steven Moffat as show runner, these arc have become more complex. I do enjoy them, but sometimes I just long for the Doctor to travel and encounter new things, letting the writers create great stories. Story arcs are a bonus, but not essential, and I would back off on them after this year, if I called the shots.
As for this season, it has been up and down for me. It is not the strongest overall (probably the 2008 season was for the revived series, and season 12 of the classic series). Here is a quick review of each episode:
The Impossible Astronaut/The Day of the Moon
Opening two parter. Great alien, with an awesome schtick (the memory thing). Confusing, but full of intriguing questions, a great guest star (Mark Sheppard, aka “Badger” from Firefly), some very creepy moments, but the ending victory seemed too easy. Plusgood.
The Curse of the Black Spot
A classic “it’s not what you think” Doctor Who story. Hugh Bonneville (Downton Abbey) shines as Captain Henry Avery. For old time Who fans, there is even a connection to the 1966 first Doctor story, the Smugglers. Double Plusgood.
The Doctor’s Wife
Penned by Neil “Sandman” Gaiman, a long time fan of the show, this is an imaginative romp mixing humor and horror and one of the most unorthodox marriages in literature. And he brings back the Time Lord Cubes, not seen since they appeared in the last Patrick Troughton episode, The War Games. Double Plusgood.
The Rebel Flesh/The Almost People
Ambitious story about the nature of sentience and the soul. While good, it mighthave been better as a single episode. As it is, it is a little slow paced. Good.
A Good Man Goes to War
This is the opposite of the previous episode, with the 44 minutes of TV over packed to almost bursting. This would have been better as a two-parter. The plot is hyper fast, sometimes glossing over moments early on, especially the character of Madame Kovarian, but still manages to make the end heartbreaking. Except for me, everyone claims to have seen the big reveal at the end coming. Add in homages to Star Wars, and it is very watchable. Double plusgood.
Let’s Kill Hitler
Best title ever. A fun romp through Berlin during the Third Reich. Great dialog, plus Rory got to punch Hitler. The whole story surround River fills in a lot of her back story and glows with intensity. The secondary story, the time-travelers that take people away right before they die to be punished for crimes is interesting but could have been developed more. This episode also suffers from the “goofy robot” syndrome. This one had weird octopus bots who, if you forget to wear your security bracelet, kill you while being very polite. Plus good.
Night Terrors
A pointless story, with only the production design of the dolls a positive. A real shame as it came from Shelock scribe Mark Gatiss. Skip it.
The Girl Who Waited
Brilliant story with great design and emotional depth. Proves that Doctor Who is more than sci-fi. It is good storytelling. And what would Rory do with two Amy’s? Downside, the goofy robots. Who designs robots without eyes so they can see with their hands? Double plusgood.
The God Complex
Great story made too close to Night Terrors. Both are claustrophobic horror stories. This one is done well, getting into the psyche’s of all the characters, and exploring the Doctor’s relationships with his traveling companions, which was (and is still) rather narcissistic on the good Doctor’s part. Also, great tie in with the Tom Baker era story The Horns of Nimon. Double plusgood.
Closing Time
Sequel to The Lodger, again brilliantly showcasing guest star James Corden. Baby troubles and insecurity are the order of the day for the Doctor and Craig. This is a lighthearted adventure that works well as a break between the tension of The God Complex and the insanity you know will be in the season finale. Also features the return of the Cybermen (and the Cybermat, last seen in 1974), and while they are a cameo, are well used. Double plusgood.
The Wedding of River Song
Check back for my thoughts.